Member-only story

The Problem of Good and Evil

Just watch out for the good

Nigelleaney
4 min readJan 18, 2025
Photo by Museums Victoria on Unsplash

The duality of good and evil is not some archetype that has always existed in the depths of our psyches, spawned from the days of our ancient ancestors. In the distant realm of Greek myths, the conflicts between good and evil rarely existed. The epic poems and tragedies do not concern themselves with this struggle, and are more engaged with the, perhaps more nuanced, individual qualities of character: nobility, wisdom, intelligence, artfulness — and other aspects of what maketh a person, great or small. So says Nick Mamatas in ‘How to Rid the World of Good’ (Everything You Know is Wrong, Ed. Kick, R. 2002, pp 163–166).

The false duality of good versus evil is based on a relatively obscure Persian prophet from the 5th century BCE. Zarathustra founded the religion, Zoroastrianism, and the concept of a monotheistic creed before it became a thing, as popularised by Christianity and Islam. Angra Mainya is their hostile, evil spirit, out to destroy and bring death to our material world. It is us humans who will eventually destroy him through our good deeds. I guess, we may be in for a long wait. Zoroastrianism also throws in a saviour figure, Saoshyant — born of a virgin who will raise the dead and herald the final judgement. No doubt you’ve heard this one before.

--

--

Nigelleaney
Nigelleaney

Written by Nigelleaney

Recently retired and completed MA in creative writing. Trying for the writer’s life with no more excuses about the day job. Named top writer in music.

Responses (1)